If ever there was a Spinal Tap story, this is it. The band was first called Axl, then Rose, then Hollywood Rose, then Axl quit & joined Tracii Guns' band, L.A.Guns. Then Axl left to rejoin Izzy in Hollywood Rose (bringing Tracii with him). The band was renamed to Guns n Roses. Before the first tour Tracii & the drummer backed out so they called in Slash and Steve Adler from another band that Duff was playing in called Road Crew. Slash and Steve joined the band two days before their first 1986 tour. Within a couple years they went from being Hollywood strip favorites to becaming one of the biggest band in the world.

Appetite for Destruction Guns N' Roses - Appetite for Destruction (Geffen) 1987

  1. "Welcome to the Jungle" (4:31)
  2. "It's so Easy" (3:21)
  3. "Nightrain" (4:26)
  4. "Out ta Get Me" (4:20)
  5. "Mr. Brownstone" (3:46)
  6. "Paradise City" (6:46)
  7. "My Michelle" (3:39)
  8. "Think About You" (3:50)
  9. "Sweet Child O' Mine" (5:55)
  10. "You're Crazy" (3:17)
  11. "Anything Goes" (3:25)
  12. "Rocket Queen" (6:13)

Love it or hate it, "Appetite for Destruction" became one of the most important metal releases of the late 80's, helping to bring an entire second round of L.A. inspired metal sounds into the mainstream. I was working at a record store in Rochester, NY called Cavages when this disc came out. I was given a promo copy and immediately loved it. I mean, who can resist the infectious shimmy and shake of "Welcome to the Jungle", "Nightrain" and "Mr. Brownstone". It was amazing, that no one had yet heard of this band. It was months later before the album just exploded with popularity. Every magazine cover had Axle's ugly mug all over it and MTV and rock radio put "Welcome to the Jungle" on regular rotation. A few of the songs on this disc even sported some 'classic metal' riffs ("Paradise City", "My Michelle"), not unlike the stuff released on the band's previously released independent EP "Live Like a Suicide." If I am not mistake, the original record I remember having didn't have the cross cover, but rather a robot-like creature attacking another robot-like creature who had just rapped some woman. This image is included in the CD insert.

Lies Guns N' Roses - Lies (Geffen) 1988

  1. "Reckless Life" [live] (3:20)
  2. "Nice Boys" [live] (3:02)
  3. "Move to the City" [live] (3:42)
  4. "Mama Kin" [live] (3:54)
  5. "Patience" (5:53)
  6. "Used to Love Her" (3:10)
  7. "You're Crazy" [alternate version] (4:08)
  8. "One in a Million" (6:08)

Basically a re-release of "Live Like a Suicide" with four new studio tracks tacked onto the end. Having a cover of Aerosmith's "Mama Kin" made this disc essential for me. However, the entire disc is actually a good listen. The four live tracks show Gn'R's roots really were in metal, as the three original tracks are much more 'classic metal' than anything the band would release after this EP. Axl Rose sings his brains out on these tracks with most of the vocals being in the higher range. Impressive! The last four tracks are a much more mellow affair. "Patience", an acoustic track, became a runaway hit, as did the incredibly insipid "Used to Love Her". Personally I can't stand this song due to the lyrics. I realize they are suppose to be tongue-in-cheek, but having those words echo through my head over and over again, just irritates me. "One In A Million" caused a bit of a controversy due to some racial slurs. Apparently this song also caused controversy within the band with Duff and Slash making public statements that they didn't agree with Axl's racial slur. Ahh, but controversy sells records, and Gn'R thrived on controversy.

Illusion I Guns N' Roses - Use Your Illusion I (Geffen) 1991
Guns N' Roses - Use Your Illusion II (Geffen) 1991

  1. "Right Next Door to Hell" (2:58)
  2. "Dust n' Bones" (4:55)
  3. "Live and Let Die" (2:59)
  4. "Don't Cry (original)" (4:42)
  5. "Perfect Crime" (2:22)
  6. "You Ain't the First" (2:32)
  7. "Bad Obsession" (5:26)
  8. "Back off Bitch" (5:01)
  9. "Double Talkin' Jive" (3:19)
  10. "November Rain" (8:53)
  11. "The Garden" (5:17)
  12. "Garden of Eden" (2:36)
  13. "Don't Damn Me" (5:15)
  14. "Bad Apples" (4:25)
  15. "Dead Horse" (4:17)
  16. "Coma" (10:08)

1. "Civil War" (7:36)
2. "14 Years" (4:17)
3. "Yesterdays" (3:13)
4. "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" (5:36)
5. "Get in the Ring" (5:29)
6. "Shotgun Blues" (3:23)
7. "Breakdown" (6:58)
8. "Pretty Tied Up" (4:46)
9. "Locomotive" (8:42)
10. "So Fine" (4:09)
11. "Estranged" (9:20)
12. "You Could Be Mine" (5:48)
13. "Don't Cry" [alt. lyrics] (4:42)
14. "My World" (1:22)

Up to this point, GnR had released in reality only one album. That album had made them some of the biggest rock stars on the planet. It took almost four years for them to complete and release their follow-up, so it had be good...and it was. "Use Your Illusion I & II" were similtaneously released and in the U.S. half a million copies of each album were sold in TWO HOURS! ouch! Within a few days each disc was beyond platinum status. According to Martin Popoff's book "The Collector's Guide to Heavy Metal," each disc sold triple platinum in Canada in three days. However, I could give a hoot about record sales. I mean, geez, Britny Spears has sold platinum plus, so has Vanilla Ice, N'Sync and a host of other really crappy artists. No one ever said that the public had taste. Unfortunately hype sells records and at the time Guns N' Roses had the hype. However, I must confess, both discs are actually quite good. I mean, there are a few bad apples in the bunch, but overall, both I and II are rock solid throughout. The metal riffing of their first disc are all but gone for a bluesier, rock n' roll vibe that is squarely Aerosmith, but man do they do it so well.

Disc one is the heavier of the two, but both are varied and have an abundance of stlye, charisma and charm. Some of my favorite tracks on Illusion I are the the rockin' opening track "Right Next Door to Hell" and the equally rockin' "The Garden" This song, coincidently, features one of my favorite artists sharing the vocal limelight with Axl, Alice Cooper. "November Rain," a brilliant power ballad, is nothing short of a masterpiece! The Beatles cover "Live and Let Die" is also outstanding. There are a couple of silly fillers on this disc, like "Back off Bitch", a song that was either included to create some controversy or to show the band had a sense of humor. I tend to think it was the controversy.

"Use Your Illusion II" is more bluesy, a tad more melancholy and contains more 'epic length' tracks than disc 1. "Illusion II" contains four songs that run over six minutes in length. The most well know of the batch being "Civil War" which was one of the songs that was released prior to the "Illusion" discs. Unlike disc one I think this one contains a fair amount of filler. The controversial "Get in the Ring" is just stupid, as is the punk-ish "Shotgun Blues." Both are just expletive soaked, juvenile attempts to show how 'street tough' the band is. Also, another version of "Don't Cry" reeks of filler. Still there is plenty of strong material on this disc as well. Duff McKagan's Johnny Thunders homage "So Fine" is cool, as is the aforementioned "Civil War". The band's cover of Bob Dylan's "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" was a huge hit for them and continues to get radio play almost a decade later. "Breakdown" has a bit of a cool Southern rock vibe and even has some banjo and Billy Gibbons-like vocals in parts ("Let Me Hear Ya Now"). One of the heavier numbers on the disc is "Locomotive" which also happens to be one of my favorite tracks on the disc. Overall, I lean a bit more towards disc one but both have their strengths and weaknesses, although the strengths on both tend to overshadow the weak spots. Neither disc, however, come close to touching the brilliance of "Appetite for Destruction."

The First Defiance Guns N' Roses - The Spaghetti Incident? (Geffen) 1993

1. "Since I Don't Have You" (4:18)
2. "New Rose" (2:38)
3. "Down on the Farm" (3:28)
4. "Human Being" (6:48)
5. "Raw Power" (3:11)
6. "Ain't it Fun" (5:05)
7. "Buick Makane/Big Dumb Sex" (2:39)
8. "Hair of the Dog" (3:54)
9. "Attitude" (1:26)
10. "Black Leather" (4:08)
11. "You Can't Put Your Arms Around a Memory" (3:35)
12. "I Don't Care About You" (2:17)
13. "Look at Your Game, Girl" [unlisted] (2:34)

This album caused a big stink because of the inclusion of a Charles Manson song. It was a publicity stunt that worked, but showed just how low a band would sink to sell records. What really sucks about that is that the Gunners really didn't need to do that. They were already the rage and the album was guaranteed to sell platinum without the extra track. In any case, "The Spaghetti Incident?" is a CD full of covers. GnR choose some odd songs to cover but play them all like they were just having fun. They play punk tracks from the Stooges, glam-rockers from the New York Dolls and rockers from Nazareth with the same conviction and attitude. Of the songs they chose, "Since I Don't Have You" was once of the worst. Not sure what they were thinking here. This song just sucks! The various punk covers work o.k. for the band. New Rose (the Damned), Raw Power (Iggy & the Stooges), Attitude (Misfits) and Black Leather (Sex Pistols) are all satisfactory covers although nothing outstanding either. Where the band excells is on the old rock classics, of which there is only one on this disc. I wish they would have chose to record more songs like Nazareth's "Hair of the Dog." The New York Dolls "Human Being" also fits the band's style a bit better than the punk songs. These are actually my two favorite songs on the album. It seems to me that GnR were trying to regain their 'from the streets' image that was lost over the years thanks to their mega-platinum selling albums, radio overkill, MTV overexposure and their hugely successful stadium tours. There are a few guests on this disc, including Micheal Monroe, who shares the vocal spot with Axle on The Dead Boys "Ain't It Fun." Duff also makes a vocal appearance taking over lead vocal duties on "New Rose". Duff actually handles all the instruments, as well as the vocals on the "You Can't Put Your Arms Around A Memory," a song written by and dedicated to Johnny Thunders. Unfortunately, this is just not a one of Guns n' Roses finer moments. However, worth the $2 I spent on it for the Nazareth and New York Dolls covers.

Live Ere '87 - '93 Guns N' Roses - Live Era '87-'93 (Geffen) 1993

1. "Nightrain" (5:18)
2. "Mr. Brownstone" (5:42)
3. "It's so Easy" (3:28)
4. "Welcome to the Jungle" (5:08)
5. "Dust n' Bones" (5:05)
6. "My Michelle" (3:53)
7. "You're Crazy" (4:45)
8. "Used to Love Her" (4:17)
9. "Patience" (6:42)
10. "It's Alright" (3:07)
11. "November Rain" (12:29)

1. "Out Ta Get Me" (4:33)
2. "Pretty Tied Up" (5:25)
3. "Yesterdays" (3:52)
4. Move to the City" (8:00)
5. "You Could Be Mine" (6:02)
6. "Rocket Queen" (8:27)
7. "Sweet Child O' Mine" (7:25)
8. "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" (7:27)
9. "Don't Cry" (4:44)
10. "Estranged" (9:52)
11. "Paradise City" (7:21)

A double live disc released in '99 that was suppose to prime channels for a new studio album, which as of 2003 still has not happened. There is certainly a wealth of material here and I can't complain about the song selections either. However, what's up with Axl's vocals sounding like they were recorded in some sort of box away from the band. Most likely the vocals were touched up in a studio. It's distracting to me how distant the vocals sound from the music. Surprisingly this disc is short of Axl's tempermental, juvenile rock star outbursts. It would have been interesting to have included a few of those times when 'ol Axl walked off stage. Despite my complaints however, this is actually an essential disc for long time GnR fans. GnR have long been a hardy and raunchy live band who usually did not fail to deliver on the stage. This disc is certainly testimony to that fact. I was surprised to hear GnR cover Black Sabbath's "It's Alright." I must have the "clean" version of this disc because the foul language is edited out and during "Used to Love Her" the word "kill" is horribly edited out. What was the point of that other than to make the song sound incredibly bad?

Greatest Hits Guns N' Roses - Greatest Hits (Geffen) 2004

1. Welcome to the Jungle (4:31)
2. Sweet Child o' Mine (5:58)
3. Patience (5:55)
4. Paradise City (6:48)
5. Knockin' on Heaven's Door (5:38)
6. Civil War (7:41)
7. You Could Be Mine (5:45)
8. Don't Cry (original) (4:43)
9. November Rain (8:59)
10. Live and Let Die (3:08)
11. Yesterdays (3:17)
12. Ain't It Fun [radio single version] (5:07)
13. Since I Don't Have You  (4:21)
14. Sympathy for the Devil  (7:18)

Guns N' Roses "Greatest Hits"? Why didn't they just repackage "Appetite for Destruction" as it is the most solid record they recorded and every song is a winner. This collection features five cover songs out of fourteen songs. Seems a bit much for a 'best of' collection, but I suppose that only illustrates my point that their best material was from their major-label debut. 

Apparently the band members didn't want this album released, especially Axl Rose who sued the record company to stop it. I have read that the band were unhappy with the track listing. (Not surprising with the inclusion of so many cover songs.) However, it's not like the record company was completely unjustified in releasing it. I mean it only took Axl a decade to deliver the promised "Chinese Democracy" record. I'm sure the band weren't too unhappy when this album actually began selling. With zero promotion the album reached number one on the UK Charts and number three on the Billboard 200 in 2004 shortly after it's release. The album is 5x platinum in the U.S., 3x platinum in the U.K., 7x platinum in Australia and 6x platinum in Ireland. 

The Deadboys cover "Ain't It Fun" is an edited version of the song with the expletive removed and replaced with a guitar chord.  "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" is a Bob Dylan cover. "Since I Don't Have You" is a cover of The Skyliners,  Live and Let Die a Wings cover and "Sympathy for the Devil" is a Stones cover. 

Chinese Democracy Guns N' Roses - Chinese Democracy (Geffen) 2008

1.    Chinese Democracy (4:43)
2.    Shackler's Revenge (3:36)
3.    Better (4:58)
4.    Street of Dreams (4:46)
5.    If the World (4:54)
6.    There Was a Time (6:41)
7.    Catcher in the Rye (5:52)
8.    Scraped (3:30)
9.    Riad N' the Bedouins (4:10)
10.  Sorry (6:14)
11.  I.R.S. (4:28)
12.  Madagascar (5:37)
13.  This I Love (5:34)
14.  Prostitute (6:15)

The last real Guns n’ Roses studio albums were released in 1991. Since then they released a handful of compilations, live albums, and a covers album. All said and done, "Chinese Democracy" is nearly 17 years in the making. There has been a lot of hype about this album for close to ten years, including how much money was spent on making this album. Of course with only Axl Rose left in the band, "Chinese Democracy" is a Guns n' Roses album in name only. What we have is an Axl solo album and a host of guest musicians including Robin Finck, Bumblefoot, Richard Fortus, Tommy Stinson, Dizzy Reed, Frank Ferrer, Bryan Mantia and Chris Pitman. So the question stands, does "Chinese Democracy" live up to the hype? Yes and no. Without the chemistry of the original band I honestly expected to be disappointed, and quite frankly, I was. This album doesn’t have anywhere near the balls of "Appetite for Destruction" or the better tracks from "Use Your Illusion". Much of this is overblown, dramatic, pop rock that lacks any real heaviness. Instead what we have is drum programming, orchestras, horns, sythns taking the place of that energy and charisma. Songs like " If The World" and "Madagascar" are just total bubblegum pop. I even hesitate to call these songs rock and roll. "This I Love" is a piano ballad that sounds like something written by Diane Warren. ("I Don’t Want to Miss A Thing" indeed!)  

Some of the harder rocking songs have a mixture of Zeppelin and Alice in Chains. The title track is a modern, hard rocker, though it sounds little like Guns ‘n Roses, save for Axl’s menacing snarl. The song has an almost punk edge to it. Likewise "Shackler's Revenge" is a decent song, though again it sound very little like Guns n’ Roses. This song has a slight industrial vibe, complete with all sorts of computer noise. "Scraped" is one of the harder rocking songs on the album. As with the others, very little resembles what I think of when I think of Guns n’ Roses. Only "Rhiad and the Bedouins" comes anywhere near sounding like a genuine Guns n’ Roses song. I also enjoyed the bluesy vibe of "Sorry".

Frankly, there was no way that Axl’s version of Guns n’ Roses could ever live up to the hype he built up. The ridiculous delays, hype and suspense only contributed to the letdown. In my opinion Axl needs to swallow his pride a bit and hook up with his band and put out a real Guns n Roses record. Real attitude. Real chemistry. Real rock and roll. As a solo release, "Chinese Democracy" isn’t bad, but it’s no where near what I want to hear from GnR.

Related Collections:
Duff | Slash's Snakepit | Izzy Stradlin

Back to Index